COVID-19 Announcement
RE: ESSENTIAL SERVICES

Mueller Legal Solutions o/b Katherine Mueller is an essential service, available for business, while operating in accordance with Order issued by the Premier of Ontario, and is practicing and encouraging social distancing measures for the safe health of all persons. Learn More [61] Essential services include professional and social services that support the legal and justice system;
[65] Professional services including lawyers and paralegals, engineers, accountants, translators.
Order of the Premier of Ontario | March 23 2020 8:00PM

 


May a Judge In Small Claims Court Make Rulings In An Equity Rights Case?

The Small Claims Court May Hear Cases With Legal Issues Involving Equity Law If Claims Seek Monetary Compensation or Return of Property. The Small Claims Court Is Unable to Order Specific Performance, among other legal issues.
A Helpful Guide to Understanding the Various Legal Issues Resolvable Within Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Equitable Relief Jurisdiction Significant debate among legal practitioners often arises as to whether the Small Claims Court holds jurisdiction for claims brought seeking equitable relief.  Although the debate arises regularly, the answer to this question appears as well addressed.  Per s.  23(1) of the Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O.  1990, c.  C.43, as below, it appears clear that the Small Claims Court holds jurisdiction over any Action, rather than Application, where the relief sought is for payment of money or the return of personal property, for the amount claims, or value of the property for return, is $25,000.00 or less per the currently prescribed amount.  Specifically, the Courts of Justice Act grants power to the Small Claims Court to adjudicate on matters as follows:

23 (1) The Small Claims Court,

(a) has jurisdiction in any action for the payment of money where the amount claimed does not exceed the prescribed amount exclusive of interest and costs; and
(b) has jurisdiction in any action for the recovery of possession of personal property where the value of the property does not exceed the prescribed amount.

As for the breadth of possible issues that may arise and the jurisdiction of deputy judges in the Small Claims Court to address the broad range of issues, per at was said in Ontario Deputy Judges Association v. Ontario, 2005 CanLII 42263 (“ODJA”) that:

[18] Deputy judges can hear a wide range of cases and have broad jurisdiction over proceedings involving the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, defamation, creditors' rights, intellectual property claims, estate litigation, and medical malpractice, among others.  Deputy judges also exercise a form of equitable jurisdiction, which adds to their role and responsibilities as judicial officers.  The Small Claims Court can hear and determine all questions of law and fact and may make orders considered just and agreeable to good conscience.

As for the capacity to address claims in equity, the same view stated in ODJA was very well reasoned and articulated by the Division Court in 936464 Ontario Ltd.  v. Mungo Bear Ltd., 2003 CanLII 72356 at paragraphs 9 to 40 and by the Court of Appeal in Grover v. Hodgins, 2011 ONCA 72 at paragraphs 13 to 50.

Mueller Legal Solutions provides Small Claims Court services for clients located in Mulmur, Caledon, Orangeville, Shelburne, Brampton, among other places!

Fill out the form below to Arrange for a Consultation

Do not send confidential information through this website form.  This website is not intended to provide advice specific to your particular circumstances.  Use this website form only to arrange an introduction with a representative to discuss your particular circumstances.  Your IP Address is: 40.121.136.229

For more information, fill out the form below to send a direct inquiry to Mueller Legal Solutions

ATTENTION: Confidential information regarding your case must not be sent through this website.  This website is not intended as providing legal advice nor intended as a method to establish a legal-representative/client relationship.  Do not include confidential details about your case by email or phone.  Use this website form only to arrange an introduction with a Mueller Legal Solutions o/b Katherine Mueller representative, before taking any steps to discuss the particulars of your legal case.  Legal advice cannot be provided to you via reply email or over the phone.  Your IP Address is: 3.226.243.36
Mueller Legal Solutions

11 Kingsland Avenue
Mulmur, Ontario,
L9V 3H1

C: (519) 278-6494
O: (226) 916-0563
E: mueller.legalservices@gmail.com

Hours of Business:

Monday: 9:00AM – 5:00PM
Tuesday: 9:00AM – 5:00PM
Wednesday: 9:00AM – 5:00PM
Thursday: 9:00AM – 5:00PM
Friday: 9:00AM – 5:00PM

By appointment only.  Please call for details.

Services Within:

Mulmur
Peel Region
Mount Forest
Collingwood
Caledon
Schomberg
Orangeville

 

Shelburne
Kleinburg
Bruce County
Grand Valley
Owen Sound
Nobleton
and much more

MUELLER
LEGAL SOLUTIONS

SSL Secured Trust https://muellerlegalsolutions.ca


Animated Spinner